05. December 2012 · 4 comments · Categories: Trump

Donald Trump has criticised William Grant & Sons for awarding the Glenfiddich Spirit of Scotland “TopScot” award to Michael Forbes. Severin Carrell has the full story in the Guardian.

The full media release from Trump International Golf Links Scotland is available here.

It’s also 282 days since we launched campaign to have Donald Trump Sen, Donald Trump Jun. and George Sorial sacked as GlobalScots. You can sign the petition here.

NOTE:- the photograph is the only one I have ever taken that won an award. it was taken in the burn of my parents’ croft on the Isle of Skye in 2004.

27. November 2012 · Comments Off · Categories: Environment, Land Use, Politics, Trump

I am very grateful to Ross McConell for helping me to interpret Trump Golf Club Scotland’s accounts.

(This post was originally published on 28 Feb 2012 and has been updated to include the 2011 Accounts)

Many claims have been made by Donald Trump over the amount of money he has invested in his golf course in Aberdeenshire. For example, in the Scotsman on 16 November 2011, Trump International Scotland’s executive vice president, Sarah Malone said that “We’ve spent well in excess of £50 million”. She goes on to claim that all the money is “Mr Trump’s own money”. Donald trump himself claimed in May 2010 that he had invested $60 million in the project.

How about we have a look at the facts?

The land is owned by Trump International Golf Club Scotland Ltd, (TIGCS) a company registered in Scotland No. SC292100 and with its registered office at 20 Castle Terrace, Edinburgh and incorporated on 21 October 2005. Accounts for the company have been lodged up until 31 December 2011 (see links at foot of this post). Over the 6 reported years:-

TIGCS has made operating losses totalling £3,909,419.

TIGCS has fixed assets of £20,155,690.

TIGCS has debts of £25,061,814 of which £24,333,162 is long term debt.

The accounts are abbreviated accounts in accordance with Section 444(3) of the Companies Act 2006. According to the accounts prepared up to and including 2008, the debts were owed to Mr Donald J Trump. In 2009 and 2010, no report is given of whether any of the Directors are creditors but it is understood that the long-term debt of the company is all owed to Mr Trump.

The published accounts confirm the following picture.

Menie Estate acquired for around £6.7 million

Investment in the golf course since then of £13,455,690.

Now personally, I do not regard the acquisition of the land as an investment in Scotland (it may be an investment for Mr Trump). It is merely a transfer payment to the previous owner in the USA. If I pop round to my neighbour’s house and hand over £500,000 to buy her vineyard in Languedoc, I have made no investment in France.

Interpret this as you will.

1) As of 31 December 2011, Trump International Golf Club Scotland Ltd. invested £13.4 million in the Menie golf resort since 2005. This is around one quarter of the figure provided by Sarah Malone in November 2011 and a third of the figure quoted by Trump back in May 2010.

2) If you include the land and operating losses, then Trump has invested £25 million.

Accounts 2006

Accounts 2007

Accounts 2008

Accounts 2009

Accounts 2010

Accounts 2011